Learning to Embrace “Positive Deviance”: Why Rule-Breakers Are Often Right
The following contribution comes from the KaiNexus portal, which describes its mission as follows: “We are on a mission to spread continuous improvement.”
KaiNexus enables leading organizations across all sectors to involve more people in improvement efforts, thereby accelerating the pace of change and maximizing impact. By using KaiNexus, companies gain the visibility and essential reporting needed to make better decisions regarding continuous improvement.
The speaker for this session is Paul Wainwright, Managing Director of Initi8 Business Excellence. The session is introduced by Mark Graban, Vice President of Improvement and Innovation Services at KaiNexus.
About the Speaker
Paul Wainwright is the Managing Director of Initi8 Business Excellence, a consultancy that specializes in helping organizations achieve positive, progressive change. The eight core elements of the Initi8 model focus on: strategy, design, leadership, processes, change, the customer, learning, and empowerment. Wainwright has extensive experience leading business improvement projects, implementing continuous improvement frameworks, and working with senior executives to develop their leadership and management competencies across various sectors. He holds a *Lean Six Sigma Black Belt* certification and actively collaborates with leaders to conduct *gemba walks* (workplace walkthroughs) and address operational improvement challenges. Additionally, he teaches in an MBA program at a local university and provides pro bono consulting to local charitable organizations, helping them formulate and implement operational strategies. He holds a BSc (Hons), an MSc, and an MBA, and is a professionally accredited *Chartered Manager* (CMgr MCMI).
The Flawed Approach of Most Change Programs
Most organizational change programs are based on a specific premise regarding how change actually works. The premise is, roughly, as follows: management identifies a problem, designs a solution, communicates the urgency of that solution, and implements it throughout the organization. Employees who comply are considered “good employees,” while those who object are viewed as resistant individuals who must either be won over or, failing that, bypassed.
Paul Wainwright’s session explains why this model is fundamentally backward and why, in many of the organizations he has worked with, those who object are often the very people who best understand what is not working.
Wainwright, a *Lean Six Sigma Black Belt* certified professional, is the managing director of Initi8 Business Excellence, a UK-based consultancy that operates across various sectors and organizations of all sizes. His perspective on leadership during change processes is informed by his experience working directly where change must actually take place: with frontline staff—who are asked to work in new ways—and with middle managers, who are responsible for translating management’s intentions into daily practice. This viewpoint offers a different explanation for why so many change initiatives stall, as well as a different recommendation regarding where to look for the people capable of making change successful.
This recommendation is somewhat uncomfortable: often, the individuals capable of making change work are the very people the organization has labeled as “problematic.”
These are employees who question protocols, frontline workers who bend the rules in pursuit of better outcomes, and middle managers who challenge initiatives that do not truly fit the situation at hand. Drawing on various sources—such as Francesca Gino’s book *Rebel Talent* and the work of Pascale and Sternin on “positive deviance”—Wainwright refers to these individuals as “positive deviants”: people who depart from organizational norms in a way that produces positive results. The central thesis of the session is that organizations that learn to recognize and foster positive deviance achieve better change processes than those that attempt to impose conformity; furthermore, the leadership behaviors that distinguish these two approaches are sufficiently concrete to be put into practice.
How traditional change actually unfolds
Wainwright began by describing the typical pattern of organizational change, using language that will be familiar to anyone who has witnessed such processes.
A change initiative is launched from the top of the organization. Profit margins shrink, performance declines, and competitors gain ground. Whatever the trigger, senior leadership meets at the highest level and makes a decision—often expressed in phrases like “we need to improve,” “we must become more efficient,” or—Wainwright’s favorite—”we are going to adopt the *Lean* methodology.”
The message reaches its destination. The silence that follows in the room is telling, as is the eye-rolling from those present. The change is presented as urgent; if a critical situation does not already exist, one is manufactured. Following Kotter’s playbook, a sense of urgency is established through a negative narrative: the iceberg is melting, the platform is on fire, or the company risks being left behind. The message cascades down the organizational structure to middle management, who are tasked with executing something they do not fully understand—and perhaps do not even believe in.
By the time this sense of urgency reaches those who perform the work that creates real value, several things have happened:
The urgency has become diluted as it passed through the various levels of the organization. The terminology that made sense in the boardroom—EBITDA, working capital, book-to-bill ratios—is meaningless to operational staff. Employees, who may have been pointing out the underlying problem for years, now see someone they don’t even know proposing a solution to an issue they had identified long before management took notice. Their skepticism is well-founded: the change is perceived as just another initiative to be endured until it passes. The collection of comments that Wainwright has gathered regarding this stage of organizational change is, unfortunately, highly representative: “My boss doesn’t believe in this, so why should I?”, “I’ve been telling them for years, Paul, but they don’t listen,” “It’s just a passing fad; it’ll blow over.” All these reactions stem from management behaviors that have become entrenched over years of similar initiatives. This skepticism is not irrational; it is the logical, cumulative learning of people who have seen this cycle repeat itself in the past.
The organization’s response to this skepticism is often worse than the original problem. Managers build walls around their teams to shield them from external interference. These walls also serve to safeguard the managers’ own ideologies and the comfortable routines they have established over the years. Anyone who questions the established way of doing things is viewed as a threat to be managed, rather than as a source of input to be considered. The walls become structural, and the organization develops an immune system against the very perspectives that could help it improve.
The Two Anxieties Triggered by Change
Wainwright drew upon Edgar Schein’s theoretical framework to explain what lies beneath the resistance manifested in surface-level behavior.
Change triggers two distinct types of anxiety; confusing them inevitably leads to poor change management.
“Survival anxiety” is the fear that something fundamental is at stake—that the business might fail, that one’s position might disappear, or that one might be laid off. The threat concerns the continuity of one’s own role.
“Learning anxiety” is the fear of being unable to meet the demands placed upon one: “I can’t learn this,” “I lack the necessary capacity,” or “I will lose my status or authority.” The threat concerns one’s perception of one’s own competence and position.
Both types of anxiety trigger different reactions and require distinct responses. A common organizational pattern—which Wainwright described as nearly universal—involves intensifying survival anxiety in order to drive change: “If we don’t reach this goal, the future doesn’t look good for any of us.” The intention is to create enough urgency for people to overcome their inertia and engage in the change.
However, the result is often the opposite. When survival anxiety is artificially intensified, people are not motivated to participate; instead, they are driven to protect themselves. The “fight-or-flight” response—which arises in the face of heightened survival anxiety—blocks the very cognitive functions (creativity, openness, learning) that change requires. As Mark Graban noted during the Q&A session, when people are pushed into a “fight-or-flight” state, the areas of the brain capable of generating new ideas and considering alternatives are the first to be inhibited. The neurochemistry of survival is not the same as that of innovation.
Schein’s recommendation—as well as Wainwright’s—is to do exactly the opposite. Rather than intensifying “survival anxiety,” the focus should be on reducing “learning anxiety.” The goal is to keep survival anxiety at a level slightly higher than learning anxiety—ensuring that change remains perceived as valuable—while simultaneously mitigating the personal fear that such change might expose an individual’s shortcomings or jeopardize their status.
The practical steps are concrete: offer a positive vision of what success looks like, rather than merely presenting a negative vision of what failure would entail.
Reinforce the message through appropriate training, rather than expecting people to figure out how to proceed on their own. Involve leaders at every stage of the process, rather than delegating the change and then stepping away. Recognize that learning often happens informally, outside of a classroom setting. Create conditions that allow people to express themselves candidly. Lead by example. Align organizational structures and systems to support the change, rather than penalizing those who attempt to implement it. Although this may seem obvious when reading it, Wainwright points out that, in practice, changes are almost never implemented this way. This is because the common tendency—the “default” approach—is to intensify survival anxiety, and most leaders have not been trained to act any differently.
What does “positive deviance” actually entail?
The turning point in the session occurs when the discussion shifts from explaining why traditional change management approaches fail to presenting what actually works. Wainwright’s answer is “positive deviance.”
Operational definition: positive deviance refers to behaviors that depart from the norms of a reference group but generate a positive effect within the organization. For a behavior to qualify as such, two conditions must be met: it must break established norms, and the outcome must be positive. If the deviation causes harm or negative consequences, it is not “positive deviance”—it is simply deviance.
This concept is rooted in sociology—a discipline where deviance has long been studied—offering insights that can be applied to organizational contexts far more directly than most leaders realize. Functionalism suggests that deviance is a necessary element in any social system and that, often, deviant behaviors point to flaws within the system itself. Structuralism posits that deviance is, in fact, a consequence of conformity to a group: the “deviant” individual is simply someone who does not go along with the crowd. Interactionism views deviance as a negotiated perspective, defined by those who hold the power to determine what is considered acceptable. Marxism, meanwhile, argues that norms and values are constructed by those in power to preserve the rules that benefit them. Both approaches have their equivalents in the organizational sphere: corporate culture defines what is acceptable, and the “deviant” is one who rejects that definition. Whether this rejection constitutes a problem or an advantage depends on whether the prevailing definition actually serves the interests of the organization.
Wainwright offers a personal example that helps clarify this concept. Every morning, on his way to work, he travels along a stretch of road with a 30-mile-per-hour speed limit. He sets his cruise control to that speed, while other drivers routinely overtake him, exceeding the posted limit. According to the legal definition of the rule, it is the other drivers who are deviating from the standard; however, according to the social norm—that is, the actual behavior of the majority—it is Wainwright himself who turns out to be the “deviant,” as he fails to conform to what the majority does. By this same logic, a cyclist or someone riding a Segway on that same road would be considered even more “deviant.”
This example is significant because it demonstrates that deviance is not an intrinsic property of a behavior, but rather a relationship between that behavior and the norms of a specific group at a given point in time. The Toyota Production System, for instance, was once considered “deviant” in relation to the manufacturing norms that prevailed at the time. Decades later, that same system has become the global standard, and now it is those who employ traditional manufacturing methods—based on batch processing and queues—who are considered “deviant.” The relationship has inverted, even though the underlying behavior has remained the same.
In an organizational context, a “positive deviant” is someone willing to challenge any level of the existing culture:
from visible artifacts and stated values to the underlying assumptions that Schein identified as the deepest layer of culture. Such individuals do not accept that things must necessarily be the way they are; they are not swayed by the argument, “But we’ve always done it this way.” Conversely, they seek opportunities to do things differently, aware that while some of these initiatives will lead to better outcomes, others will not.
The traits of a “positive deviant”
Wainwright drew on the work of two researchers to describe what “positive deviants” are actually like.
From the book *Rebel Talent* by Francesca Gino, several traits emerge that are worth examining individually. Positive deviants embrace their inner rebel; they do not apologize for wanting to do things differently. Gino cites the example of a renowned Italian chef who takes classic dishes and adds a unique twist; although he faced significant resistance early in his career, he held fast to his convictions and, over time, achieved global fame and earned several Michelin stars.
Positive deviants seek opportunities to step outside their comfort zones, knowing that feeling uncomfortable is a prerequisite for genuine growth. Like curious children, they constantly ask questions, thereby broadening their understanding rather than merely protecting what they already know. Recognizing that they cannot know everything, they actively seek out perspectives different from their own; they understand that diversity contributes to success and that what matters most about a person is not their demographic profile, but what they can contribute to the team. They focus on developing their strengths rather than obsessing over their weaknesses. They foster engagement through storytelling, helping others understand how their individual contributions fit into the bigger picture.
Pascale and Sternin offer additional, complementary traits. Positive deviants look for “invisible innovators”—people and opportunities that others fail to notice. They identify outliers and exceptions. They learn through action, which inevitably involves making mistakes, yet they continue to move forward. They also allow others the choice to opt out if they so desire. Furthermore, they allow individuals to discover their own solutions to their problems and, subsequently, enable them to take ownership of those solutions.
The resulting profile is that of a curious individual—someone comfortable with discomfort, who rejects the conformity imposed by status, who is generous in recognizing the capabilities of others, and who is willing to make mistakes in public for the sake of achieving something better. It is not a particularly flattering self-portrait—not the kind most leaders would want to be compared to—but that is, in part, the point: it is difficult to foster “positive deviance” in others if you are not capable of practicing it yourself.
Transactional Leadership vs. Transformational Leadership
The next question that arises is: what kind of leader creates the conditions necessary for “positi